Article Response #4

UN accuses Russia of violating human rights in Crimea

Russia is committing "grave human rights violations" in Crimea, according to a report by the United Nations.


The UN human rights agency says it has documented arbitrary arrests, torture and at least one extra-judicial execution in the region.


"There is an urgent need for accountability," UN human rights chief Zeid Ra'ad Al Hussein said.


Russia annexed the peninsula from Ukraine after the country's pro-Russian leader was overthrown in 2014.


In response to the report's accusations, one Crimean official complained the account was not objective and did not reflect reality.


The UN report cites "grave human rights violations, such as arbitrary arrests and detentions, enforced disappearances, ill-treatment and torture, and at least one extra-judicial execution".


It adds that there have been "intrusive law enforcement raids of private properties" which "interfered with [the] right to privacy".


Crimea: The place that's rather difficult to get into


The report, which says the human rights situation has "significantly deteriorated" in the region, notes that hundreds of prisoners were illegally transferred from Crimea to Russian jails.


It says civil servants were forced to renounce their Ukrainian citizenship or face losing their jobs, and condemned Moscow's decision to replace Ukrainian laws with Russian ones.


"Education in Ukrainian has all but disappeared from Crimean schools," the report adds.


It is based on interviews conducted from mainland Ukraine, as human rights investigators were not permitted entry into the region.






Crimea, which has a Russian-speaking majority, voted to join Russia in a referendum that was not recognised by the international community.


The UN says Crimea's Turkic-speaking minority, the Tatars, who make up 12% of its population, have been targeted.


The Tatar parliament, the Mejlis, boycotted the referendum on joining Russia. Moscow said it was an extremist organisation and banned it last year.


Crimean Tatar leader jailed by Russian court


"While those human rights violations and abuses have affected Crimean residents of diverse ethnic backgrounds, Crimean Tatars were particularly targeted especially those with links to the Mejlis", the UN report says.


It adds that the ban on the Mejlis "has infringed on the civil, political and cultural rights of Crimean Tatars".


Mr Hussein accused Russia of failing to investigate alleged human rights violations.


He said: "Failure to prosecute these acts and ensure accountability has denied victims proper remedy and strengthened impunity, potentially encouraging the continued perpetration of human rights violations."


But Zaur Smirnov, a member of the Crimean regional government, told Interfax that the UN report was filled with anti-Russian rhetoric and had used data from Ukrainian monitoring groups.


http://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-41386490




opinion:

Audience - I think that the intended audience is to the Crimean people, specifically the refugees that have fled there.

Bias- Although i can't really be able to identify a strong bias in the article although i did notice the use of emotion that the author portrayed in their tone to create a certain bias to draw in readers, and concerned citizens especially in the line: "The UN report cites "grave human rights violations, such as arbitrary arrests and detentions, enforced disappearances, ill-treatment and torture, and at least one extra-judicial execution" (BBC). The structure of the article also presented a certain feeling of emotion also, when they introduce the problem then later mentioning the hardships of the oppressed citizens were going through. In my opinion this was a great use to raise further notice not just to the people groups but also neighboring countries experiencing the same hardships.

Purpose- To raise alarming awareness to the countries and the world not to treat places like Crimea the same way.